I've been trying to figure out just what their secret is. When I saw this Princess Bakery Emulsion, I thought I might be on to something.
Now, I don't think it's the secret to Potbelly's cookies, and I still like the vanilla-almond flavor of my regular cookies, but it is nice. It adds a certain creamy orange/nutty taste.
Remember these? I used the Princess flavoring in them. My brother-in-law asked if I had done something different with the cookies and said that he really liked them. It gave me great pleasure to tell my Iraq war vet, personal trainer brother-in-law that what he liked was PRINCESS bakery emulsion. :)
So, if you're looking for a new flavor to shake up your sugar cookies, this just might work for you.
And, Potbelly...if you're out there...can you tell us your secret, please?!?For more WFMW ideas, visit Kristen at We Are THAT Family. My WFMW archives are here.